Top 13 Best Bars For Halloween In New York City

Top 13 Best Bars For Halloween In New York City - a close up picture of Halloween decorations in a bar

New York City, known for its pulsating nightlife, takes on a hauntingly thrilling aura as Halloween approaches. Amidst the sea of events and parties, certain bars and lounges stand out, transforming into ghoulishly glamorous spots that celebrate this spirited holiday in style. Welcome to our guide, ‘Top 13 Best Bars For Halloween In New York City,’ where we showcase the finest watering holes that go the extra spooky mile to deliver a nightmarish yet fun-filled experience.

As the city’s spook-a-licious spots gear up to offer you a spine-tingling night of trick or treat, creaking doors of these bars open up to tantalizing cocktails and hair-raising celebrations. Buckle up for a mystical tour of enchantment and terror, for this ain’t your average pub crawl. So, without further ado, let’s dive deep into the heart of NYC’s night scene, discovering the best spots where things go clink in the night.

Best Bars For Halloween In New York City

1. Beetle House

A Tim Burton-themed bar providing an immersive gothic experience for fans and visitors. The bar is decorated with memorabilia and themes from Tim Burton’s iconic films, offering a distinctive and eerie atmosphere.

2. The Cauldron NYC

This magical and mystical bar combines the art of mixology with fantasy, offering guests a chance to immerse themselves in a spellbinding environment where they can create their own potions.

3. Oscar Wilde

Celebrating the extravagance of the Victorian era, this bar offers an opulent ambiance reminiscent of 19th-century luxury, adorned with period-appropriate decorations.

4. Lillie’s Victorian Establishment

Step back in time in this Victorian-themed bar and restaurant, where the charm of the 19th century is brought to life with authentic antiques and traditional cuisine.

5. Magic Hour Rooftop Bar & Lounge

Experience the largest indoor/outdoor hotel rooftop bar in NYC, designed with a unique urban amusement park concept, complete with captivating views of the Empire State Building.

6. E’s Bar

A relaxed neighborhood bar where friends can gather for a night of games and comfort food, embodying the spirit of a classic casual joint.

7. Duff’s Brooklyn

Dive into the hardcore world of this gritty, metal-themed dive bar, known for its intense ambiance and dedicated community of metal enthusiasts.

8. The Flying Fox Tavern

Discover a hidden gem with a mysterious, vintage vibe, offering a quaint escape for a night filled with intriguing cocktails and conversations.

9. Watermark Bar

Enjoy the serenity and beauty of the waterfront at this bar, blending sophistication with relaxation, offering panoramic views of the Brooklyn Bridge.

10. Citroën Brooklyn

Escape to this French-inspired cocktail bar, where the ambiance of a chic Parisian bistro is recreated, complete with vintage decor and an intimate setting.

11. Fraunces Tavern

Step into history at one of NYC’s oldest bars, offering a unique blend of American culinary tradition and rich historical ambiance, echoing the spirit of the American Revolutionary War.

12. Paradise Lost

Immerse yourself in a unique blend of tropical paradise and gothic darkness, creating an unforgettable Halloween-themed experience.

  • Address: Not available
  • Phone: Not available
  • Website: Paradise Lost
  • Unique Features: Fusion of tropical paradise with dark, gothic undertones.
  • Best Seller or Highlights: Forbidden Fruit, Lost Soul

13. Loreley’s Haunted Beer Garden

Experience the festive spirit of a German beer garden with a haunted twist, offering a unique Halloween experience alongside traditional German brews and cuisine.


With a wide array of options, New York City’s Halloween bar scene offers places that stand a cut above the rest. These 13 bars magnificently blend ambience, tantalizing cocktails, and Halloween festivities to provide unforgettable experiences. Whether you’re seeking scary-themed decor or exclusive Halloween events, the Big Apple has got you covered. There’s no better city to raise your spooky spirits in style this Halloween!

Scott is the editor-in-chief of Spice Market New York. He is also an author and publisher of his own craft.