The Best Pizza In Midtown NYC

The Best Pizza In Midtown NYC

Pizza is one of the most well-known dishes in New York. With some of the best pizza joints in the world, it’s no surprise that NYC consumes hundreds of thousands of pizza slices every day. Have you been to New York if you haven’t enjoyed a slice of pizza?

A thick and crispy crust along the edge distinguishes New York-style pizza. However, the dough beneath the toppings is soft and thin. Folding the large and wide slices in half is simple. A Chicago-style pizza, on the other hand, a Chicago-style pizza is a thick-crust, deep-dish pizza baked in a pan.

Pizza joints may be found on every corner in New York City. The options available to you can be rather bewildering. We’ve compiled a list of the best locations in NYC to satisfy your pizza cravings, whether you want a big pie or a piece. After all, everyone should have a fantastic, real pizza in New York on their bucket list.

Juliana’s Pizza

The Italian ambiance is apparent, with crimson awnings, rustic furnishings, and white and red checked cloth napkins. The pizzas are served hot from the stone oven and are quite tasty. If you’re traveling to a large party, expect to wait. There are even barrier tapes in front of Juliana’s for those waiting.

Grimaldi’s Pizza

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is the name of a pizza chain started in 1941 in New York. Each pizza is baked in handcrafted coal-fired ovens in the classic Italian style. For a long time, New Yorkers have known that the pizza is the best in the city, which is why it is so popular. As a result, wait times should be considered – however it is worthwhile to wait for a table.

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza on MacDougal Street

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is a great place for a late-night supper because it’s open until four a.m. every day. This pizza serves classic deep dish slices from New York City, accessible by the pie or slice to satisfy any appetites.

Artichoke, crab, Margherita, vodka, state island, Sicilian, pepperoni, and meatballs are among the eight diverse varieties of their famous pizza. Depending on your desire, you can order individual slices or pies. This classic New York-style pizza is ideal for capping a night out with friends. It’s simple but tasty.

Pizza Pot Pies

If you’re searching for a quick, cheap, and easy meal, Pot Pie is the place to go. This spot is ideal for any time of day, with a broad choice of pizzas, as well as other menu items such as sandwiches and salads.

Pizza Pot Pie’s build-your-own-pizza kit allows you to choose your ingredients and have them wrapped up in a personal-sized pie, making it ideal for a family get-together or a romantic date night.

Each pie is created with fresh ingredients and roasted in a wood-fired oven for an unmatched flavor. They offer traditional tastes like cheese and pepperoni and vegan, hemp, and white pizzas and entertaining appetizers like pepperoni rolls, chicken parm rolls, and garlic knots.

Pizza Pot Pie is sure to have something to satisfy your pizza cravings, no matter what style of pizza you’re seeking. Discover for yourself why this pizzeria is one of the most popular on Bleecker Street.

Don Antonio

Everything on Don Antonio’s menu is wonderful, but their fried pizza is the actual reason to visit Don Antonio instead of other New York pizza joints. I had no idea fried pizza existed until I came here, even though you can now eat everything fried. In any case, this pizza is going to transform your life!

Lombardi’s Pizza

Lombardi’s takes pride in being the United States’ first pizzeria. Since 1905, Gennaro Lombardi has been based in Naples. The original store is in Little Italy, and a second location is in Chelsea.

Pizzas are baked in a coal oven at “America’s first pizzeria.” Pizza with a thin crust. The style is Neapolitan. Fresh ingredients. The crust is tough—an authentic, comfortable atmosphere with many images on the walls. No one has more pizza-making experience than you. It’s a cash-only situation!


From the outside, the restaurant appears to be a regular Italian eatery. You’ll feel quite at home: there are excellent red wines a friendly ambiance, and you’ll undoubtedly be among the locals. Because of its great cooking, the Rubirosa is one of the most popular Italian restaurants in town. The pasta and the appetizers (such as grilled calamari) are reminiscent of Italian cuisine, as is the pizza.

If you’re searching for a late-afternoon glass of wine and some nibbles, or a wonderful evening meal, this is a good option. There’s also a pizza hour, where you can get two pizzas for the price of one!

Roberta’s Brooklyn has a lot of cultures and fantastic shopping, but it also has some of the best pizza in the city. Roberta’s is located in Bushwick, near the L train station. If you haven’t already, try their “Famous Original” or “Cowabunda Dude” pizzas. You won’t feel unduly stuffed when you complete a full pie because the flavors blend perfectly.

BigA Bite

Big pizzas are served here, as the name implies. BigA Bite is a terrific experience for parties because they may be up to 8 feet long (or for families with big appetites). The pizza dough is light and fluffy, and the toppings are plentiful. Before you begin, make sure you sample the Pizzini. Alternatively, try the Spicy Burrata!

The Best Pizza Slices in New York City

The tastiest pizza in New York is available not only in pies but also in slices! Many pizzerias serving prepared slices may be found in the metropolis, where many people seek a quiet snack on the go. Even if you’re not in a hurry, many of the slices are great and worth trying. We’ve compiled a list of our favorites to save you time and calories while hunting for the greatest pizza slices in NYC.

Prince Street Pizza

In SoHo, Prince Street Pizza is a must-try. You’ll likely have to wait in line for a while, but trust us when we say it’ll be worth it. If you’re not sure what to order, we recommend the pepperoni pizza. The famous pizza joint is well-known, especially among celebrities. Inside the shop, the walls are covered with photos of people who have visited Prince Street Pizza.

Bleecker Street Pizza

It’s impossible to discuss the top Bleeker Street pizza shops without Bleeker Street Pizza. It’s no surprise that this place has a line that wraps around the entrance, having been rated the greatest pizza in NYC for three years in a row by Food Network. The pizza is made in the typical New York style, with a thin and crispy dough topped with cheese and toppings of your choosing.

The pizza recipe that this establishment uses sets it apart from the competition. The “Nonna Marie Pie” was created using an old family recipe when Bleeker Street Pizza opened in 2004.

While there are many more flavors to pick at a reasonable price, the Nonna Maria and Grandma Pizzas are the best to sample. A typical pepperoni pizza slice, on the other hand, cannot be beaten.

John’s of Bleecker Street

Giovanni Sasso, an immigrant from Naples, Italy, first started John’s of Bleecker Street on Sullivan Street in 1929 before moving to its current location along Bleecker Street. Since then, many people looking for some of the best pizza in NYC have turned to this location.

John’s pies are baked in coal-fired brick ovens, giving each piece a distinct texture and flavor that you won’t find anywhere else. Fresh ingredients are used in their typical New York-style pizzas, including handmade sauce made from Italian plum tomatoes, mozzarella cheese stacked with fennel sausage, or pepperoni if you’re really hungry! 

While they have many alternatives than just classic square slices here, if you want something simple but tasty, nothing beats one of their plain old pepperoni slices. In one of their old-style original wooden booths with an art deco decor, enjoy their classic Sasso Pies. It has aged mozzarella and tomato sauce, or their famous John’s Bianca, which has aged mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, basil, and no sauce.

Joe’s Pizza 

Joe’s Pizza is another original on Bleecker Street for pizza. This location has been around since 1975, when Pino Pozzuoli, an immigrant from Naples, Italy, founded it. Joe’s Pizza is well-known for serving up some of the city’s greatest traditional New York pizza slices.

Joe’s Pizza is well-known for its dependability and loyalty. They still utilize the same 1975 recipe, and it’s still a family-owned business overseen by Joe, the founder. So don’t expect any elaborate mixtures or slices here. You’ll instead find delectable, fresh New York-style pizza.

While you can order extra toppings and specialty pies over the phone, the easiest way to get a taste of Joe’s is to order one of their cheese, mozzarella, or Sicilian square slices. If you’re feeling peckish, they also sell fresh salads served family-style upon request.

Basille’s Artichoke Pizza

The Pizza of Artichoke Basille is no longer a secret. The pizza chain, which opened its first shop in the East Village in 2008, now has twelve locations across the country, three in New York City.

The pizza is served in huge pieces, assuring that you will be satisfied after only one. When choosing your slice, you can’t go wrong with their most renowned slice, the artichoke slice, which is also the name of the pizza joint. Artichoke hearts, mozzarella, and pecorino romano cheese are layered on a white cream sauce. Crab, Margherita, Vodka, Sicilian, and Meatball are among the other topping options.

A slice of pizza costs $7 and comes on plain paper plates. Native New Yorkers, travelers, and even celebrities frequent Artichoke Pizza. Artichoke Pizza has been featured on several shows throughout the years, including The Tonight Show. Most foodies will agree that this is the best pizza slice in New York City.

Mama’s TOO

In New York, this tiny pizza shop provides cheap pizza slices. You can get everything from traditional slices to gourmet triangles and square slices—several unusual flavors on the menu, such as Cacio e Pepe. Pepperoni, on the other hand, remains the true crowd favorite. They curl up slightly at the edges, giving them a sharp feel.

Mama’s TOO has a counter service option. Remember that the venue is tiny, so you might not be able to get a seat immediately away, depending on your timing. If you don’t mind eating outside, simply walk over to Straus Park and sit on a bench.

Pizza Loves Emily West Village

Located on Bleecker Street in the West Village, Pizza Loves Emily is NYC’s most popular pizza eaterie. This place, created by Emily and Matt, a couple who fell in love over a slice of pizza, is ideal for sitting down, relaxing with friends or family, and enjoying some drinks. Plus, their lovely patio area is dog-friendly, so that you can eat your pie outside with Fido as well.

The topping possibilities offered and the unique combination of specialized pizzas distinguish Pizza Loves Emily. The Emmy Burger Pizza, with LaFrieda beef, Emmy sauce, caramelized onion, American cheese, and pickles, is a must-try, as is the Arenstein, with pepperoni, pickled chili, and honey.

If you’re not in the mood for pizza, there are plenty of other high-quality menu items to select from, such as their crispy chicken sandwich and truffle mac and cheese. If you’re looking for something simple but tasty, you can’t go wrong with a basic Margherita pizza.

2 Bros Pizza

The New York-based pizza restaurant is a New York staple that claims to serve the best pizza in the city, and thousands agree. Whether you’re searching for a cheap piece or a big pie, we’ve got you covered. You’re in good hands with 2 Bros! The iconic $1 slices will thrill your taste buds with a crunchy crust and juicy toppings with a crunchy crust and juicy toppings.

Aside from their tasty slices and reasonable prices, 2 Bros Pizza is known for its extensive operating hours. It’s the ultimate comfort food for people who need a quick bite, particularly after a night out in the city.

Di Fara Pizza

Do you want to go to Brooklyn for a slice of pizza? New Yorkers make the journey to Di Fara solely to enjoy Chef De Marco’s delectable pizza. Wafer-thin and widely regarded as one of the greatest in the city, it’s another of our New York favorites for repeat offenders.

Gelso & Grand

The Gelso & Grand is a well-balanced restaurant (with outstanding pizza), a bar, and a little outdoor space. It is extremely elegantly equipped, serving excellent espresso in the traditional Italian style. The audience is diverse, from families with toddlers to couples and business espresso visitors.

Two Boots West Village

Two Boots Village is where to go if you’re searching for a unique pizza experience. The V for Vegan, which is created with artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, sweet red pepper pesto, and non-dairy cheese, is a local favorite, as is the Bayou Beast, which is made with spicy shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapenos, and mozzarella and is a spin on a Louisiana meal.

There are many unique flavors to delight any palate, regardless of whatever pizza you choose. Two Boots specializes in doing distinct cajun-Italian cooking, which is only accentuated by their eclectic setting, instead of standard New York Style Pizza.

Their restaurant is furnished with works by local artists, giving it the ideal spot for a slice of pizza and catching up with friends or family. Whatever you order, the superb food and excellent service at Two Boots Village will leave you happy.

Village Square Pizza

Village Square Pizza offers a one-of-a-kind and delectable menu that will please everyone. You’re guaranteed to find something for even the pickiest diners with options like their buffalo chicken pizza or the eggplant square pizza. If you don’t want to try something new, go for the classic, cooked with a family recipe tomato sauce, extra virgin olive oil, grated parmesan, and whole milk mozzarella.

This restaurant is fantastic for groups, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply catching up with friends. Large pizzas are available, including classic and specialty versions and garlic knots and calzones. Their pizza slices make a night out at Village Square Pizza simple and economical, regardless of your order.

No worries if you can’t make it to the restaurant. You can get Village Square Pizza online using your local delivery apps, so you’ll never miss out again.

Numero 28 Pizzeria

Numero 28 Pizzeria is where to go if you want authentic Neapolitan pizza. This restaurant is dedicated to serving the best pizza in town, and they succeed admirably. Their pizzas are handcrafted with fresh ingredients and roasted in a wood-fired oven for an unmatched flavor.

What makes Numero 28 so special is that their pizza has a distinct flavor. They include basic varieties like cheese and pepperoni and more creative flavors like mozzarella, mushrooms, and truffle oil. Their five formaggi are prepared with five distinct types of cheese. They also have other high-quality dining alternatives such as chicken parm, broccoli rabe, or baked ziti, as well as calzones, sandwiches, and salads if you’re truly hungry.

Numero 28 Pizzeria is a must-visit if you’re seeking a terrific pizza experience. They not only have some of the best pizza in town, but their distinct tastes will keep you coming back for more. Furthermore, its ambiance is ideal for both parties and date nights.

Jr.’s Pizza and Brew

If you’re searching for a late-night slice of pizza and a cold beer to wash it down, Jr’s Pizza and Brew is the place to go. This place is great no matter what time; it is open into the early morning hours. Customers can order salads, calzones, pasta, and sandwiches in addition to traditional slices.

Their menu consists primarily of pizzas, with over 20 varieties ranging from classics like cheese and pepperoni to unique flavors like their primavera pizza, which includes broccoli, spinach, tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese, and their Lasagna pizza, which is filled with ground beef, mozzarella cheese, ricotta, and tomato sauce. Plus, these pizzas are not only delicious, but they’re also big! Their medium pizzas serve up to three people, so there will be plenty of leftovers.

Jr’s Pizza and Brew is the place to go if you’re looking for a simple, no-fuss pizza joint with delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere. Before you go out for a night on the town, check out their great draught specials.

Percy’s Pizza

Percy’s Pizza is ideal for a laid-back night out. They’re conveniently located on Bleecker Street, making them accessible from everywhere in the village. Percy’s is renowned for its huge pizza slices, ideal for satisfying any hunger.

Percy’s provides more interesting varieties, including spicy eggplant pizza and upside-down pizza, in addition to their classic cheese and pepperoni slices. Plus, you can always make your pizza with your favorite toppings and have it delivered right to your door, ensuring that you can enjoy their excellent food at any moment.

Spunto Thin Crust Pizza

Sppunto Thin Crust Pizza is a laid-back pizza joint ideal for a night out with friends or family. The thin-crust New York-style pizzas are cooked in a wood oven to achieve the greatest flavor. Aside from their delectable pies, they also serve fresh salads and a variety of appetizers such as hummus, garlic knots, Rotella, and bruschetta.

From meat lovers’ pizzas stuffed with pepperoni and sausage to vegans seeking a veggie-filled pie, their menu has something for everyone. There are also vegan options available! You’ll find it difficult to select between your favorite flavors with so many options, so take advantage of Spuntos’ create-your-own-pie option and add all of your favorite toppings.

Spunto’s has the perfect pizza for everyone, no matter what flavor of pizza you crave! If you’re looking for a great New York-style thin-crust pie, this Bleecker Street location should be on your list of places to visit.

Pizza Tours in New York

Still haven’t had your fill of pizza? You can go on a pizza tour to sample more than one pizza. Pizza is such a popular cuisine in New York that tours are dedicated solely to it. So far, the best pizza tours we’ve tried are

A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza Tour

The A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza Trip is a sightseeing tour, bus tour, and walking tour all rolled into one. It all begins in Union Square Park in Manhattan, when you drive to Brooklyn with your New York guide to learn about some of the city’s most important areas, including Sunset Park, DUMBO, Bay Ridge, and Coney Island.

This walking tour will take you to the locations where movies like Goodfellas, Once Upon a Time in America, and Annie Hall were filmed, as well as two of Brooklyn’s best pizzerias because pizza and New York are inextricably linked!

Greenwich Village Pizza Walk

Pizza and New York are inextricably linked. This walkthrough of Greenwich Village and Little Italy is one of the most popular food tours in NYC, second only to the famed Brooklyn Pizza Walking Tour. Three pieces of pizza from various stores are included in the ticket, and you will learn a lot about these districts from a New York guide during the trip.

Do you know the important health and safety items that one should carry while traveling? Visit this blog post to learn more about it.

Cecilia Solomon
She is one of the amazing people in the company. She is in charge of all the admin work as well as human resources.